Best Toilet Flange Reviews – Top 10 Selections From A Pro!

Life is beautiful when everything going well. When you find your toilet making bad smell from sewer gases or your toilet is leaking water around the toilet bowl, you may lose your sound sleep until you fix it. In this case, you badly needed to replace your toilet flange.

Sometimes people find it very much difficult to find out the perfect effective toilet flange for their toilets. This article will provide everything you needed for the best toilet flange of 2021.

Best Toilet Flange – Comparison


Product Name


Dimensions (inches)


NEXT BY DANCO Perfect Seal


6.18 x 6.18 x 2.41

Oatey GIDDS Replacement Flange


12.67 x 7.51 x 4.93

NEXT BY DANCO Toilet Flange

Stainless Steel

7 x 1 x 7

PlumBest C54402 3-Inch by 4-Inch Flange


6.8 x 6.7 x 3.6

Sioux Chief Closet Flange


4 x 7 x 7

A toilet flange is the communication point between your toilet and the floor drainpipes. It helps to remove any sewer gases to spread out from the toilet or prevent any leakage. It is very essential to find out the good toilet flange for your toilet as it is not possible to replace the toilet flange frequently.

This review is prepared by analyzing all the necessary information including the product quality, customer review and the customer support and other preferences. This review also comes with an effective buying guide that will also help you to make your decision quickly.

Best Toilet Flange Reviews for 2021

1. NEXT BY DANCO Perfect Seal Toilet Wax Ring

DANCO is very popular as well as one of the largest industries for the repair, replacement of plumbers. It provides the actual toilet flange that you are looking for. You can replace your toilet flange by NEXT BY DANCO Perfect Seal Toilet Wax Ring. It will provide the maximum performances that you expect.

NEXT BY DANCO Perfect Seal Toilet Wax Ring

NEXT BY DANCO Perfect Seal Toilet Wax Ring ensures a perfect seal on the toilet installation. The rubber gasket makes no mess in the toilet installation. It also removes all kinds of harmful sewage gases with a tight seal.

It also creates three times stronger seal than any other toilet flange. It is perfect for the heights from 1/2 inch above and below from the floor. The adapter’s inner dimension is 2-5/8 inches. The inner dimension of the center of the seal is 2-3/8 inches.

This toilet flange provides a repositionable facility. It is durable and it is very much replaceable toilet flange. You can remove the black plastic ring situated in the gray rubber casing if the toilet does not sit flush to the floor.


  • Provides perfect seal
  • Three times stronger seal
  • Suitable for any flange height
  • Provides reposition facility
  • Creates no mess as it features a rubber gasket
  • Very much affordable


  • Crack under high pressure

2. Oatey GIDDS-173390 43539 Replacement Flange

Oatey GIDDS-173390 43539 Replacement Flange Forcast Iron is perfect for residential and commercial applications. It has gained the name and fame with the best services to the customers. All the products are made with the proper quality.

Oatey GIDDS-173390 43539 Replacement Flange

It features PVC plastic compression. It is suitable for the 4-inch pipes along with the 3-inch stainless steel bolts. You can replace your broken cast iron closet flanges with it. The perfect unrestricted flow design makes it more usable and effective.

It is easy to install. No additional tools are required to install it. You don’t need to tear up your existing floor to install this toilet flange. This product is proudly manufactured in the USA. You can also get the technical as well as customer support from the company.


  • Easily fits with toilets
  • Easy to install
  • Can be installed with the existing floor
  • Perfect design
  • Features 3-inch stainless steel bolts


  • Heavier than another toilet flange

3. NEXT BY DANCO (10672X) HydroSeat Durable Toilet Flange Repair

DANCO is one of the largest companies in this sector and they come with different models of toilet flange for the customers. So, it comes again on our list. NEXT BY DANCO (10672X) HydroSeat toilet flange is perfect for the wobbly leaky, damaged and broken toilets.

Best toilet flange

This toilet flange is perfectly designed to fit most of the standard toilets. This design allows fitting most of the pipes and collars. It assures a perfect seal for a tight fit. It also removes any sewer gas smells. The self-centering gasket also helps to make a tight fit. It makes a hassle-free seating on the toilet.

It features HydroSeat, 4-1/2 inch steel screws as well as stainless steel washers and nuts. It is durable and provides better performances. It is also easy to install. High-quality materials provide effective usages.


  • Provides perfect seal
  • Self –centered gasket makes a tight seal
  • Features HydroSeat with rubber funnel
  • Ensures durability
  • Easy to install


  • In some cases, despicable materials are used

4. PlumBest C54402 3-Inch by 4-Inch PVC Offset Closet Flange

Jones Stephens Corporation has more than 40 years’ experience in the industry in this sector. It has gained recognition nationally for the plumbing products. PlumBest C54402 3-Inch by 4-Inch PVC Offset Closet Flange is one of the desired toilet flanges for the replacement of runny, damaged or broken toilet flange.

PlumBest C54402

It features plastic materials in its constructions. The plastic ring is very much strong and it won’t deteriorate. You can enjoy the 360-degree rotation of this toilet flange. There are separate two radial and grooved slots for the closet bolts. It is suitable for the 3-Inch x 4-Inch toilet flange. It fits 2 inches over or 4 inches inside schedule 40 DWV pipe.

It comes with the plastic swivel ring that makes perfect seal in the toilet. You will experience fewer knockouts using it. The 360-degree rotation helps to use it in any direction. There are six holes for the screw to secure it to the floor.


  • Non deteriorate plastic ring
  • Features 360 degrees rotation
  • Features six screw holes
  • Makes perfect seal
  • Features closet bolts
  • Durable


  • Installation is not easy

5. Genova Products 75158S Universal Closet Flange (Not Available)

If you are looking for economical as well as modern toilet flange, Genova Products 75158S Universal Closet Flange with Stainless Steel Ring can be your best fit. It comes with the modern mechanical closet flanges. It is manufactured and produced in China. It is a great replacement solution if you have a leaky toilet ring, damaged or broken toilet rings.

Genova Products 75158S

It is a universal closet toilet flange. It means it makes a perfect fit for most of the toilets. It comes with a stainless steel ring. It makes it stronger comparing any other traditional toilet flange. The modern technology is used in the design and for manufacturing. It is installed with the cast iron or PVC-DWV pipe. The size of the pipe is 4 inch. It is made of steel with a dimension of 3.6-inch height. The side to side width is 7 inches. The front to back width is also 7 inch.

It is durable and easy to install. It is very much easy to use. It provides great customer flexibility. It is very much effective with the new or old model toilet.


  • Very much economical
  • Perfect for the replacement of toilet ring
  • Manufactured in modern technology
  • Comes with the steel materials
  • Manufactured in China


  • Does not feature with crews or bolts

6. Sioux Chief Closet Flange Push-Tite Pvc 3″

If you are searching for a high-quality toilet flange, you can choose Sioux Chief Closet Flange Push. It is proudly manufactured in the United States. It is perfect for the new or old model toilets. If you have difficulty with your old toilet flange or you are facing a leaky toilet flange, broken or damaged toilet flange, you can use Sioux Chief Closet Flange Push.

Sioux Chief Closet Flangejpg

It comes with high-quality materials. The quality and efficiency are checked before it is delivered to the market. The package is 10.6 inches long and 17.9 inches wide. The package is 22.4 inches in height. It comes with plastic materials. This toilet flange makes a great seal to the toilet.

This product is so durable and provides user flexibility. You don’t need to replace this toilet flange again within a short time after using it. It is easy to use and easy to install.


  • Makes perfect seal
  • Easy to install
  • Provides durability
  • Ensures effectiveness
  • High quality plastic PVC materials


  • Crack under high pressure

7. OATEY 43405 Set-Rite Toilet Flange

If you want to replace your toilet flange with the new design and technology, you can choose OATEY 43405 Set-Rite Toilet Flange. It makes a perfect seal on the floor. It works perfectly with the existing floor or surface.

OATEY 43405 Set-Rite Toilet Flange

It is perfect for the toilet flange sealing surface. If your toilet flange is uneven, broken or cast iron, you can replace it with this one easily. It makes a great seal of your toilet. So, you don’t have to worry more about water or gases. You will find only code approved toilet flange on the market. It ensures the quality of the product.

It is made of high-quality plastic materials. The high-quality products make it more durable. It is suitable for most of the toilets. It is very simple to install.


  • Provides tight seal
  • Made of high-quality plastic materials
  • Durable constructions
  • Code approved toilet flange
  • Proper toilet flange sealing surface


  • Tricky for the first installation

8. Oatey 43538 ABS Cast Iron Flange Replacement

Oatey is one of the leading toilet flange manufacturing company. It produces different models of flanges according to the demand of the customers. So, this company product comes to our list several times. Oatey 43538 ABS Cast Iron Flange is one of the perfect toilet flanges for the replacement. You can choose it for the perfect design with the performances.

Oatey 43538 ABS Cast Iron Flange

This product features slides inside of 4 inches cast iron. Again it features 40 DWV plastic pipes. There are also 3 inches stainless steel bolts for the tight seal. You will need no caulking. The compression joint can be fitted up to 3 inches. The design of the toilet flange is smooth and unrestricted.

This toilet flange is easy to install. You can install it with the simple tool and no additional tools are required. Again, you don’t need to tear up the existing floor to install it. The quality materials ensure long-lasting facilities. It also makes hassle-free usage.


  • High-quality plastic pipe
  • Caulking is not necessary
  • Tearing the existing floor is not necessary
  • Stainless steel bolts are provides
  • Easy to install


  • Without the wax ring, the air odors may leak

9. Flexon Toilet Flange for 4″ PVC, ABS, Cast Iron or Lead Pipes

If you want to buy a new toilet flange or you want to replace your current one with a new one, Flexon Toilet Flange can be your first choice for your toilet. The high-quality materials and the modern design make it unique comparing the others.

Flexon Toilet Flange

This toilet flange features 4 inches of ID pipes. It can adjust the minimum of 3/8 inches to a maximum of 1 1/8 inches height. You don’t need any wax in this feature. It makes a perfect flexible seal inside the pipe. It features flanges along with spacers and brass bolts, screws and nuts. There is also a toilet seat gauge to check the seal. The surface of sealing is thick and it fits nicely around the outlet.

It is manufactured in the USA. The quality is always ensured. Hence, it provides a long-lasting facility. It is easy to assemble. As it works without wax, it is really helpful for the customers.


  • Suitable for different heights
  • Flexible flange
  • Features spacers and brass bolts, screws, and nuts
  • Provides durability
  • Proudly manufactured in the USA


  • May cost faster rust

10. PASCO 21013 Toilet Flange Repair Metal Quick Ring to Repair (Not Available)

PASCO 21013 Toilet Flange is a great solution for the damaged, broken closet toilet rings. It makes fresh concrete without actually extending beyond the toilet. The affordable price makes a great deal for the repairing broken closet flanges. The durable metal components make it better than any other usual toilet flange.

PASCO 21013 Toilet Flange

It provides great services for the metal, cast iron, plastic closet flanges and so on. It comes with an integrated design to make the perfect seal. It is very much strong and makes a strong fit so that you don’t have to replace it very often. The solid rings make a perfect seal of the toilet. LASCO 33-3738 and Pasco 21013 are the two models of this toilet flange.

This toilet flange provides a long-lasting facility. You can install it with all around the body of flange. You can also enjoy an easier DIY installation. You will not need any kinds of additional equipment for the installation. It can be the perfect solution if your toilet flange got broken.


  • Easy to install
  • Features solid ring
  • Comes with durable components
  • Fits most of the toilets
  • Ensures durability


  • Does not feature with crews or bolts

What to Consider at the Time of Buying a Toilet Flange

It is very much important to replace your toilet flange with the best one as it will make you tension free for a long period. Low-quality toilet flange not only costs your money but also makes your life full of sufferings with the sewer of gases and leakage of water. This buying guide will surely help in buying the best toilet flange.


Compatibility is very much needed for any kind of replacement for all sectors. You cannot buy anything useless as it does not make a perfect fit. As you are discussing the toilet flange, the compatibility of the toilet flange refers to the size of the toilet drain pipe of the floor.

Usually, there are two different sizes are found. One is three inches and another is 4 inches of the drain pipe. So you need to know the size of your toilet drain pipe size before you make your decision.

You need to be careful with the size because fault size won’t solve your problem rather it makes the problem bigger. You can also buy the universal size of the toilet flange as it can fit will all types of the toilet. But the things you need to remember that perfect size make the perfect fit.

Different Types of Seal

If you consider the toilet flange as a total unit, a seal is one of the most important and most critical parts of the toilet flange. You can see the variation of the toilet seal. In the market place, you can discover three types of toilet seal-like rubber, wax and silicone seal. You can choose any one of them as your preferences.

Wax seal is very much useful for the tight fit. If you are having a problem with the leakage, it can be your solution. But with the change of temperature, the wax seal may get damaged. If the temperature is too high or too low, the wax ring can melt or make a mess. Again if you move to your toilet the wax may get damaged.

Rubber seal and silicon seal work almost similarly. They also make a good seal with the long-lasting facility.

Materials Integrity

Materials are always crucial for any kind of product. In this case, it is very much important to buy a toilet flange that belongs to a high quality product. Toilet flanges are made of different materials. Plastic, copper, cast iron, aluminum is very common.

You can see most of the toilet flanges are manufactured with plastic materials. PVC is one kind of special kind of plastic that is used for making most of the toilet flanges. In some cases, you can see the whole part of the toilet flange is made with the PVC plastic and in some cases, you can see there are the uses of both PVC plastic and metallic horn.

You can also see some of the toilet flanges are made with copper. The remarkable part of this material is it is more resistant than others. If you are considering the cast iron, it is very much expensive considering the other toilet flange. Although it is expensive, it provides long-lasting performances. The aluminum toilet flange is lightweight and they provide durability and effective performances.

Flange Height

Flange height can make a great significance at the time of replacing your toilet flange. You need to check the height of the drainpipe of your floor. If you want to renovate your bathroom floor, you need the toilet flange with more height as your bathroom floor raised a bit.


You always need a durable toilet flange. As durability depends on other aspects like materials, seal, and others, you can make sure that all the things come with the perfect specifications. The best company ensures the quality of their products and thus they ensure the long-lasting performances of their products.


Installing a toilet flange is not so much simple or so much difficult. To make the installing easy most of the toilet flange comes with proper instructions. You will not need any additional tools for installing most of the toilet flange. But you need to be careful at the time of installing the toilet flange.

Warranty and Customer Support

All the best products provide the warranty along with the best customer services. You can check their website to get customer support and warranty details.


Replacing your toilet flange frequently is not a good task to do. This product review is made to keep you far away from replacing the toilet flange after done it for once. In this review, all the best toilet flanges of 2021 are listed that can make your task easy.

You need to read through the article carefully and make the right decision according to the right fit for your toilet. You will get many options to buy a toilet flange but it will be unwise if you make your decision without gathering any idea about your necessary things. You can feel free to buy any one of our list matching with your toilet model.

Leave a Comment